"Don't Trust Your Gut"
Harvard Business Review
by Eric Bonabeau, May 1, 2003
Making high-stakes business decisions has always been hard. But
in recent decades, it's become tougher than ever. The choices facing
managers and the data requiring analysis have multiplied even as the
time for analyzing them has shrunk. One simple decision-making tool,
human intuition, seems to offer a reliable alternative to painstaking
fact gathering and analysis. Encouraged by scientific research on
intuition, top managers feel increasingly confident that, when faced
with complicated choices, they can just trust their gut. The trust in
intuition is understandable. But it's also dangerous. Intuition has
its place in decision making--you should not ignore your instincts any
more than you should ignore your conscience--but anyone who thinks
that intuition is a substitute for reason is indulging in a romantic
delusion. Detached from rigorous analysis, intuition is a fickle and
undependable guide. And although some have argued that intuition
becomes more valuable in highly complex and changeable environments,
the opposite is actually true. The more options you have to evaluate,
the more data you have to weigh, and the more unprecedented the
challenges you face, the less you should rely on instinct and the more
on reason and analysis. So how do you analyze more in less time? The
answer may lie in technology. Powerful new decision-support tools can
help executives quickly sort through vast numbers of alternatives and
pick the best ones. When combined with the experience, insight, and
analytical skills of a good management team, these tools offer
companies a way to make consistently sound and rational choices even
in the face of bewildering complexity--a capability that intuition
will never match.
The full article may be purchased through the HBR web site, or you can send a request to .
|